Essay, Research Paper: Christianity Questioned


Free Religion research papers were donated by our members/visitors and are presented free of charge for informational use only. The essay or term paper you are seeing on this page was not produced by our company and should not be considered a sample of our research/writing service. We are neither affiliated with the author of this essay nor responsible for its content. If you need high quality, fresh and competent research / writing done on the subject of Religion, use the professional writing service offered by our company.

In “Christianity and the Machine Age,” Eric Gill attempts to prove that
Christianity is true. To answer this question, Gill turns not to philosophers,
theologians or archaeologists, but to his own consciousness. “If there be God,
if there be Christ,… it is to man, to the individual man that he calls.”
(Gill, 219) Gill bases his argument on the presumption that the truth is the
correspondence of thought with thing. “In Christianity thought and thing
correspond. It is in that sense that we say Christianity is true, is the
truth.” (Gill, 219) Gill says that what he knows of Christ corresponds with
what he knows and desires and loves as a human. Gill also asserts that he has no
reason to suppose that he is any “different in kind or in powers or in
experience from other men.” (Gill, 219) Gill says it follows that since
Christianity is true for him, it must then also be true for all men. According
to Gill, those who do not accept the truth of Christianity are simply wrong.
Gill continues, asserting that Buddhism, Hinduism, Islam and all other faiths
are lesser because they are “more partial, less profound, and therefore less
widespread.” (Gill, 219) This is a poor argument considering that Christians
were a minority group for thousands of years. While Gill does not feel that
other faiths are untrue, he says that the only faith with a clear view of
reality is Christianity. “Observe, for example, an object under a microscope.
Attempt to get it into focus. But, unless the object be absolutely flat, you
will get one level in focus and not another. You will not be able to see it all
at once, and you will perhaps pass some levels altogether.” (Gill, 219) This
metaphor is an excellent way to explain why so many differing religions exist
when there is only one Truth. Gill does not, however, provide any reason to
assume that Christianity is seeing the truth any more clearly than the other
major world religions. The argument that Christianity is more correct because it
“affirms” more sets Christianity as the lowest common denominator. This does
not prove that the truth as seen through the Christian ‘microscope’ is any
clearer that when the truth is viewed through any other religion’s
‘microscope.’ Gill’s point about denials is well made, however. “The
only thing to beware of is denial. It is on the plane of denials that we fall
foul of one another.” (Gill, 219) I agree with Gill that it is more productive
to examine the commonalties than the conflicts when comparing religions.
Gill’s purpose in attempting to answer such a profound question is tied to his
definition of proper work in the Age of Machines. “Christianity…must imply
something as to the object of human life and the object of human work.” (Gill,
220) Gill says that if Christianity is removed from the process of work, the
work(wo)man will be lowered to a subhuman condition by degrading labor and
focusing on profit-gaining ends. For Gill, this is the true threat of the
Machine Age. “The effect of the Machine Age is to secularize human life, to
abolish the Christian criterion of holiness, understood both morally and
intellectually.” (Gill, 235) Gill does allow that machines may help to
alleviate some of the suffering that exists in the world, but he has no
confidence that the influence of capitalist industrialism will be overcome.
“The spirit which has animated merchants and industrialists and financiers
from the beginning of the Machine Age, whether in big business or small, is not
the provision of social amenity or the relief of suffering, but the
aggrandizement of themselves.” (Gill, 235) For Gill the only hope for humanity
lies in the creation of a Christian world, a world based on “Christian faith,
ruled by Christian thought, and moved by a Christian will.” (Gill, 236) I
agree with many of the values and ideals that Gill espouses. It is obvious that
something must change, particularly with regard to the overemphasis on the
profit motive. I do, however, disagree with his notion that these ideals can
only be applied through the template of Christianity. Christian leaders have
shown themselves to be no more fair or humane than non-Christians. Neither has
the influence of Christian religious leaders, particularly Catholic leaders,
been proven superior. If fact, the countries most deeply entrenched in
industrial capitalism are predominantly Christian. Any challenge to the status
quo, whether issued by a Buddhist or a Christian, would be an excellent start in
the effort to change the way the world views work and working people. Gill’s
presumption that only Christianity holds the answer is misguided.
Good or bad? How would you rate this essay?
Help other users to find the good and worthy free term papers and trash the bad ones.
Like this term paper? Vote & Promote so that others can find it

Get a Custom Paper on Religion:

Free papers will not meet the guidelines of your specific project. If you need a custom essay on Religion: , we can write you a high quality authentic essay. While free essays can be traced by Turnitin (plagiarism detection program), our custom written papers will pass any plagiarism test, guaranteed. Our writing service will save you time and grade.

Related essays:

Religion / Christianity
Christianity is one of the major religions of mankind. It has been the dominant religion in Europe and America, Christianity has also spread throughout the world and has a greater number of adherents...
Religion / Christianity
Christianity is one of the most widely practiced religions in the world today. It is based around the belief of one supreme ruler, God. The main guide that Christians base their life around is a book...
Religion / Christianity
A common type of Email that we receive states that "denomination X" is not Christian" -- where "X" may refer to the Jehovah's Witnesses, Mormons, Roman Catholics, the United ...
There is an expanding church in Pine Hill that I attend each week. This church is filled with many great spiritual people who are like family in which you could share your struggles of life with and ...
Religion / Cloning Issue
Genesis 11:1-9 records the sad story of the building of the tower of Babel. That project stands out as the first chapter in a story that continues to this day, and includes many similar kind of under...